Marr energy project goes under PINS microscope
A public inquiry into plans for a 190-acre solar farm near Doncaster has started, Enviromena’s proposals having been refused against officer recommendation in 2025.
The proposal was refused at committee in the face of officer recommendation, with applause from the chamber audience reported in the media.
The plans are for land close to the Marr Grange farm shop and tea rooms, south of Barnsley Road.
A critical matter had been that the site’s designation had changed in the run-up to the committee session, with officers deciding that it should be defined as Green Belt rather than Grey Belt.
Although the recommendation had still been to approve, with the potential benefits outweighing the downsides in the view of officers, committee rejected it.
Applicant Enviromena, which is working with Stantec, immediately announced its intent to appeal the decision, highlighting a recent Planning Inspectorate decision that had rejected a local planning authority view of Green/Grey belt designation.
Three grounds for refusal were given: inappropriate development in the Green Belt; unacceptable landscape and visual impacts on the area, including the Marr conservation area and the farm shop/tea room; and the loss of best and most versatile agricultural land.
2026 – the story moves on
A planning committee meeting in March was told that the council’s position would be to not defend on Green Belt grounds – this followed a decision on Wrotham Parish Council vs the Secretary of State.
Furthermore, following a PINS-convened meeting just ahead of the inquiry, City of Doncaster Council officers declared on 11 November that it will not defend on “loss of best and most versatile agricultural land” due to the applicant/appellant compromising, by submitting a grazing management plan the previous week.
As set out in the officer report, “this is the first time such a condition has been proposed”, continuing that “the LPA has consistently made the point as part of its appeal case that, whilst the Appellant had suggested sheep grazing of the land whilst the solar farm operation was possible, they had offered no evidence that it was feasible nor made any commitment to doing so”.
Essentially, what remains to be ruled on is the impact of the scheme on the landscape and local amenities.
The council’s case includes expert testimony from Gillespies on landscape impact.
In terms of Biodiversity Net Gain, there appear no points of contention. As set out by officers in a report on the Section 106 agreement should permission be given, the proposed ecological enhancements would deliver a 221.54% net gain in area-based habitat units, a 52.19% net gain in hedgerow units, and an 86.72% net gain in watercourse units, all far above the uplifts required.
As reported: “The proposed ecological enhancements would therefore be a valuable benefit to City Of Doncaster Council and worth securing in the event that permission is granted for the appeal development.”
The appeal began at The Point, South Parade, Doncaster on Tuesday 17 November, with five sitting days expected to be required, with two days held in reserve. The appeal reference is 6010146 and 26/00018/REF and City of Doncaster’s original planning reference 23/02634/FULM.

